[Change Request] Change code of Turn monitor on/off

[Fredi009sg]

Description

Since a while raspi core were modified and has removed "vcgencmd display_power" its not anymore possible to turn on and off the monitor. Which works for me as an alternative is the following code "xrandr -d :0 --output HDMI-1 --off" for turn monitor off and "xrandr -d :0 --output HDMI-1 --auto" for turn monitor on. Is there any change that you adjust the code ?

Changelog

No response

Requirements

No response

Additional info

No response

[kurnon]

This explains why my display hasn't been shutting off. Your suggestion did not work for me.

[ezeholz]

Hi! Thanks for reporting this issue.

I'm not an owner of a RPi, so I cannot test those commands myself, but since there're many users of RC, we cannot take this change lightly. However, you could set you own config.js to point into the right direction, please check our FAQ and some older issues (#284 (comment)) to understand better my point.

Hope you stay well!

[biejay]

Would appreciate as well!

[Killator]

Hi everyone,

I finally understand why my home automation couldn't turn off my mirror anymore... Thanks @Fredi009sg !
Moreover, your workaround proposal just work fine to turn OFF and ON the HDMI output.
(my setup: rPI3B / Debian Bulleye 64bit Full / Automated install script by sdetweil / MMM-Remote quick install)

Unfortunately we lose the function Monitor STATUS... I did some experiments with the command xrandr -d :0 --prop but I'm not a developer and I'm at the limit of my tweaking skills.

I understand that modification should not be made without careful consideration but maybe it would be possible to support several display managers... The default would remain vcgencmd but, with some configuration, we could support xrandr, tvservice, cec-client, etc... depending on the platforms.

What do you think of this proposal ?

[github-actions]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had
recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you
for your contributions.

[ezeholz]

@Killator there're certain modifications that can be made through the config file, no development needed. You can take a look into the Remote Control Wiki to understand better what I'm trying to point.

If any of you are up to, we can modify the Wiki and let there established diferent working methods for every RPi and Linux instance, so that anyone can check which commands works in their usecase.