Skip to content
Draft
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension


Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
75 changes: 75 additions & 0 deletions PR_DESCRIPTION.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,75 @@
## Summary
Updated `learn/generation/openai/openai-ml-qa/01-making-queries.ipynb` to use Pinecone SDK v8 and added comprehensive test coverage with edge case handling for the query_helpers module.

## Changes

### Notebook Updates (Previous Iteration)
- Updated pip install command in cell 1:
- Changed: `pinecone==5.0.0` → `pinecone` (latest SDK v8)
- Removed version pin to automatically use the latest SDK v8 release
- Kept openai version pinned at `0.27.7`
- Improved variable naming for better code readability:
- Changed: `xq` → `query_embedding` in cells 13 and 19
- Makes the code more self-documenting and easier to understand
- SDK initialization patterns verified to be compliant with v8:
- Uses `from pinecone import Pinecone`
- Uses `pc = Pinecone(api_key=api_key)` for initialization
- Uses `pc.Index(index_name)` for index connection
- Uses `pc.delete_index(index_name)` for cleanup

### Query Helpers Module (Current Iteration)
- Created `query_helpers.py` with reusable utility functions for:
- Creating embeddings from queries
- Querying Pinecone for relevant contexts
- Building prompts with retrieved contexts
- Generating answers using OpenAI's completion API
- Complete end-to-end query and answer pipeline

### Edge Case Handling
- **Empty Pinecone results**: `query_and_answer()` now returns a graceful error message when no results are found
- **Empty contexts**: `build_prompt()` properly handles empty context lists
- **Long contexts**: Functions handle contexts that exceed character limits
- **Special characters**: Proper handling of queries with special characters

### Bug Fixes
- Fixed `build_prompt()` loop logic that was preventing single contexts from being included
- Added early return for empty contexts to avoid unnecessary processing

### Test Coverage
- Created comprehensive test suite with 24 tests covering:
- Embedding creation
- Pinecone querying
- Context extraction
- Prompt building (basic and exhaustive modes)
- Answer generation
- End-to-end pipeline
- Edge cases:
- Empty Pinecone results
- Very long contexts exceeding character limits
- Multiple contexts exceeding combined limit
- Missing metadata in query results
- Special characters in queries
- Whitespace handling in generated answers

## Testing
- All 24 unit tests passing
- Test coverage includes:
- Happy path scenarios
- Edge cases and error conditions
- Mock-based testing for external API calls (Pinecone, OpenAI)
- Verification of default and custom parameters
- Verified notebook uses modern SDK patterns (v8 compatible)
- Confirmed initialization code follows Pinecone SDK v8 conventions

## Notes
- Addressed all reviewer feedback from previous iteration:
1. ✅ Fixed pytest installation issue by using project's dev dependencies
2. ✅ Added handling for empty Pinecone results with appropriate error message
3. ✅ Fixed `build_prompt` to handle empty contexts properly
4. ✅ Added comprehensive edge case tests including:
- Large/long contexts exceeding prompt character limits
- Empty result sets from Pinecone queries
- Malformed data with missing metadata
- The notebook demonstrates RAG (Retrieval-Augmented Generation) patterns with Pinecone and OpenAI
- All SDK method calls are consistent with v8 API
- Query helper functions are well-documented with type hints and docstrings
Loading
Loading